Thursday, November 19, 2026 Facebook | Twitter | Linkedin
Magazine

Mining & Trade News

Malawi Online News
Home / Mining / MINING & SOCIAL ISSUES: CONTROVERSY SURROUNDING GEMSTONE EXPORT BAN: MINISTRY, MMRA, MITC AND FASMIM TAKEN TO TASK TO EXPLAIN EXPORT PROCEDURES DURING BAN
Mining

MINING & SOCIAL ISSUES: CONTROVERSY SURROUNDING GEMSTONE EXPORT BAN: MINISTRY, MMRA, MITC AND FASMIM TAKEN TO TASK TO EXPLAIN EXPORT PROCEDURES DURING BAN

November 19, 2026 / Yamikani Jimusole
...

Who authorized exports during ban? Questions over Europe and China shows while miners wait for permits

Malawi's gemstones are once again shining on the world stage, but back home miners and dealers are asking a hard question: who is allowed to shine with them? While most licence holders remain locked out by an export ban, a select delegation is exhibiting abroad, forcing the Ministry of Mining, its Departments and MMRA to explain the rules.

On 12 February 2025, the Ministry of Mining announced a temporary suspension of gemstone export-permit processing pending review of the valuation framework, reported as 21 days. This was followed by Executive Order No. 2 of 2025 banning export of raw minerals, also pending review. Two measures, now conflated, with no clear public update on their current legal status. Both were said to be aimed at fixing undervaluation, curbing illicit flows, ensuring more revenue and forex for government, and promoting value addition at home. Prior to the February ban, Geological Survey Department experts conducted physical assessment and physical inspection to determine fair market value for royalty purposes, then MMRA issued export permits. The Ministry is currently reviewing the draft Value Addition Act 2026, so it might also update when it thinks the process will end.

Information available indicates this is the second time amidst the ban that a delegation has gone to a gemstone show facilitated by MITC. The first was June 2025 during the 4th China-Africa Economic and Trade Expo (CAETE) in Changsha, China, led by the former Minister of Mining where Malawi signed MoUs worth billions including a US$7 billion deal with Hunan Sunwalk Technology Group and MITC announced US$120 million (about K230 billion) in export orders including gemstones - 30MT amethyst, 1000MT milky quartz and open-ended mica. Now eight stakeholders or their representatives travelled to Europe from 19 to 31 October 2026 under the Federation of Artisanal and Small-Scale Mining in Malawi (FASMIM) banner also facilitated by MITC.

Photographs circulating from Europe reportedly show cut-and-polished and rough stones presented under the Federation's name. Of course on the list we have seen individual companies, which raises a further question on the criteria used by MITC. Small-scale miners are calling for equal opportunities, arguing that not only Federation or associations are entitled to opportunities - any individual entrepreneur, company, cooperative and perhaps academia should qualify as long as they are competent and satisfy the requirements. The Ministry itself issues licences to individual Malawians, companies, cooperatives and other entities, who are all now eagerly waiting for the bans to be lifted.

Many small-scale mining entrepreneurs report that export permits, valuations and laboratory assessments remain suspended or restricted, leaving them unable to access legitimate markets. The prolonged restrictions have caused challenges including locked capital in unsold stones, loss of jobs and household income, and reports that some gemstones are being smuggled out through informal channels with no revenue or forex to Malawi.

That the ban is being enforced on others is confirmed by a government institution itself. In a letter dated 9th April 2026 (Ref: EDF/09/04/26) responding to CDEDI, the Export Development Fund disclosed that it had sold 299.07 grams of mixed-colour sapphires, 1.28 grams of ruby, 380.34 grams of rhodolite garnet, 26.5 grams of spinel, 2.0 grams of tourmaline, and 24.23 grams of aquamarine, generating revenue of USD 67,850.46. EDF further stated: "However, sales were halted following the export ban in February 2025, and no further sales have been recorded since then."

If EDF, a state institution mandated to buy and sell gemstones, complied and halted sales, under what authority, permit, or exemption were gemstones exhibited and orders taken in June 2025 and now in Europe during the same ban?#

It is against this background that we seek clarity from the concerned stakeholders by demanding answers to the following questions:

1. Photographs from Europe posted on the MITC page show both rough and cut-and-polished stones under the Federation's name. Were these stones sourced from Malawi and did they leave Malawi under any export permit or temporary exhibition authorisation? Which authority approved, who handled physical inspection and documentation, and who conducted valuation for royalty purposes? Before the ban, GSD experts conducted physical assessment and MMRA issued permits - who is doing this now? If lawful procedures exist to take gemstones abroad during a ban, are they published and accessible to all licensed miners and dealers? If not, what are the consequences for the Ministry of Mining, MMRA, MITC and FASMIM for facilitating exports through unpublished procedures while others remain blocked?

2. Were sales, orders or expressions of interest secured in Europe for rough and cut-and-polished stones, and how have orders from the June 2025 CAETE exhibition (30MT amethyst, 1000MT milky quartz, mica) been fulfilled during the ban? How will new orders be fulfilled? In the event FASMIM members cannot fulfill such bulk orders individually, how many members actually hold sufficient stock and grades to meet such volumes, and what will they do - will they aggregate from other miners who are currently banned from exporting, or will orders remain unfulfilled? Will the delegation receive special treatment while the rest of the industry remains blocked?

3. What are the legal implications of signing export orders and MoUs that are not fulfilled? Under contract law, an unfulfilled commercial order may constitute breach, exposing the signatory - whether MITC, FASMIM or an individual company - to liability for damages, loss of credibility for Malawi as a reliable supplier, and potential claims for non-performance. If bulk orders like 30MT amethyst were signed without verified capacity and without a lawful export route during a ban, who bears legal responsibility, and does this expose government-facilitated deals to reputational and legal risk?

4. What is the current legal position on exports of rough gemstones, cut-and-polished stones, specimens and temporary exhibition consignments under the 12 February 2025 measure and Executive Order No. 2 of 2025?

5. Did the Ministry of Mining and the facilitating agency, MITC, seek and obtain legal clearance from the Ministry of Justice and the Attorney General on whether exhibition consignments and the signing of export orders/MoUs during the subsistence of the ban are legally permissible, and if so, can that clearance be made public?

6. Why has EDF, a state institution mandated to generate forex through gemstone trading, been barred from exporting since February 2025, at a time Malawi is facing acute forex shortages? EDF itself confirms in its letter of 9th April 2026 that after generating USD 67,850.46 from gemstone sales, "sales were halted following the export ban in February 2025, and no further sales have been recorded since then." How much forex has Malawi lost by keeping EDF's trading window closed while allowing selective exhibitions abroad, and what is government doing to allow EDF to resume trading to bring in forex7. Since the trip is facilitated by MITC as a government agency, this cannot be a private association trip, and officials from the Ministry of Mining and MMRA are expected to be part of the delegation. Ministry officials were present in China in June 2025 when the CAETE orders were signed. How far has the Ministry gone in fixing the valuatio8. What are the implications of the apparent double standards, where a select group appears to access international markets under MITC facilitation during a ban while licensed miners and dealers cannot obtain permits? What safeguards exist to ensure equal opportunity, prevent market distortion and protect Malawi's credibility as a transparent mining jurisdiction?n system that triggered the February 2025 suspension, what progress has been made on the draft Value Addition Act, when will the process end, what is the clear roadmap to resume normal export permit processing that secures more revenue and forex while promoting value addition, and what is being done to assist miners and dealers to fulfil the orders being signed?

7. Since the trip is facilitated by MITC as a government agency, this cannot be a private association trip, and officials from the Ministry of Mining and MMRA are expected to be part of the delegation. Ministry officials were present in China in June 2025 when the CAETE orders were signed. How far has the Ministry gone in fixing the valuation system that triggered the February 2025 suspension, what progress has been made on the draft Value Addition Act, when will the process end, what is the clear roadmap to resume normal export permit processing that secures more revenue and forex while promoting value addition, and what is being done to assist miners and dealers to fulfil the orders being signed?

8. What are the implications of the apparent double standards, where a select group appears to access international markets under MITC facilitation during a ban while licensed miners and dealers cannot obtain permits? What safeguards exist to ensure equal opportunity, prevent market distortion and protect Malawi's credibility as a transparent mining jurisdiction?

9. What is FASMIM's official position on the ban? Is the Federation comfortable with a situation where its members or representatives appear to be allowed or given special treatment to exhibit abroad while the rest of the industry remains blocked from exporting?

These are institutional questions. The Federation, Ministry of Mining through its Departments, and MMRA should provide clear, public clarification so that rules are lawful, transparent and equal for every eligible mining entrepreneur.

While focus remains on signing trade orders, long-term success will not come from ad-hoc exhibitions during a ban. It will come from building proper infrastructure and systems: a published, functional valuation laboratory with certified gemologists, a transparent export permit portal with timelines, a clear value-addition framework that miners can actually comply with, and a credible Malawi gemstone brand at home. Trade without systems creates orders we cannot fulfill; systems create trade that lasts.

Share this:

Leave a Comment


Comments